Yellowstone Finale: The Shocking Truth About Jamie and Sarah Atwood’s Plan—Did He Know All Along?

The final season of Yellowstone has thrown fans into a whirlwind of betrayal, murder, and shocking revelations. One of the biggest mysteries of Season 5, Part 2 revolves around the ultimate betrayal—John Dutton’s unexpected and tragic demise.

But was it really a suicide, or was it a well-orchestrated plan by those closest to him? As the dust settles, one question lingers: Did Jamie Dutton know all along about Sarah Atwood’s deadly scheme?

The Unraveling of John Dutton’s Fate

The first episode of Part 2 wasted no time in delivering one of the most gut-wrenching moments in the show’s history. Within the first five minutes, Yellowstone fans were stunned by John Dutton’s death. For years, John had been the face of power and resilience, refusing to back down from any fight. So how did such a strong, unyielding character meet his end in such a quiet and shocking way?

The official ruling was suicide. But something about the way it happened—alone in his bathroom, no sign of struggle, and no forced entry—felt off. Beth Dutton, always one to trust her instincts, immediately suspected foul play. And at the center of her suspicions? Jamie.

Jamie’s Betrayal—A Long Time Coming?

Jamie Dutton, the black sheep of the family, had long been an outsider among the Duttons. His decision to align himself with Market Equities and Sarah Atwood, John’s most powerful enemies, was the ultimate act of defiance. After years of being pushed aside, manipulated, and disrespected, Jamie saw an opportunity to carve out his own path—one that didn’t involve being under his father’s shadow.

But did he truly have the courage to orchestrate John’s downfall, or was he just a pawn in someone else’s game? Enter Sarah Atwood.

Sarah Atwood: The Mastermind or a Pawn Herself?

Sarah Atwood arrived in Season 5 as a calculated, ruthless strategist working for Market Equities. From the moment she stepped into Jamie’s life, she wasted no time seducing him—not just romantically, but politically. Sarah saw Jamie as the key to dismantling the Dutton dynasty, and she played him like a fiddle.

With John standing in the way of Market Equities’ plans, Sarah had everything to gain from his removal. She manipulated Jamie, feeding into his insecurities, and convincing him that with John gone, he could finally take his rightful place as a leader. But here’s the twist—was Jamie truly in on the plan, or was he simply too blind to see Sarah’s real motives?

Did Jamie Know All Along?

In Part 2, Jamie’s reaction to John’s death was suspicious, to say the least. Initially, he seemed genuinely shocked, as if he hadn’t expected it to happen so soon or in that particular way. But when Sarah confronted him, her words sent a chill down viewers’ spines.

“You told me to take care of it, Jamie.”

At that moment, Jamie’s face fell, and reality hit him—he was the one who had given the green light. Maybe he hadn’t planned every detail. Maybe he didn’t know it would be staged as a suicide. But his silence, his willingness to let Sarah handle it, meant he was complicit in his father’s murder.

The Plot Holes That Raise Even More Questions

While the writing suggests that Jamie played a role in John’s death, there are a few inconsistencies that fans can’t ignore.

Why Would Sarah Oppose Staging It as a Suicide?
Earlier in the season, Sarah had discussions with Market Equities about the best way to eliminate John Dutton. Initially, she was against making it look like a suicide. So what changed? Did she see an opportunity to frame Jamie if things went wrong?
Jamie’s Guilt Seems Too Real
When Jamie first learns of his father’s death, he looks genuinely devastated. If he had been fully aware of the plan, would he really have been that shaken? Or was he just now realizing the weight of his decision?
Beth’s Wrath—Will She Find Out the Truth?
Beth Dutton is many things, but she is not naive. She immediately suspected Jamie, and if she finds out that Sarah Atwood was behind it, Jamie will be the first person she comes for.

What Happens Next? The Fallout from John’s De@th

With John gone, chaos is inevitable. Beth is out for blood, and if she discovers Jamie’s involvement, there’s no telling how far she’ll go. Jamie, on the other hand, may start realizing that Sarah never really cared for him—she just needed him as a means to an end.

Will Jamie try to fix his mistake?
If Jamie regrets his involvement, he might try to turn against Sarah. But if history has taught us anything, it’s that Sarah is always two steps ahead.

Will Beth take revenge?
Beth has never hesitated to destroy anyone who wrongs her, and Jamie is at the top of her list. Could their sibling rivalry finally reach its breaking point?

Could Jamie actually survive this?
Yellowstone fans are torn—will Jamie redeem himself, or will he meet the same fate as his father?

Final Thoughts: Jamie’s Fate Hangs in the Balance

As Yellowstone barrels toward its conclusion, Jamie Dutton finds himself in an impossible position. He may have believed he was finally securing his own power, but in reality, he was being used all along. Sarah Atwood saw his weakness and exploited it, and now, Jamie might have no way out.

With Beth determined to avenge her father and Sarah pulling the strings behind the scenes, Jamie’s future looks bleak. Will he find a way to outmaneuver Sarah and redeem himself, or has he sealed his fate forever?

One thing is for sure—Yellowstone is far from done with shocking twists, and the final episodes promise to be the most explosive yet.